It still exists, but when it was PHed it was moved to the
SciFi thread - it's one of the stickies at the top over there. It's the only thread I ever use over there anymore.
I guess I've been trying to figure out what to say about this ep so far that I haven't exhausted myself saying elsewhere. The squee of seeing Rose is starting to wear off, and as much as I loved seeing her already (the press-launch DVDs had the scene without Billie Piper, so it was a real surprise -
they had filmed the scene with her scenes for later episodes). But I have to agree with, okay no one said it yet I guess, the only thing I didn't like is that I really loved all the stuff that Catherine Tate did, but having Billie Piper return in her first episode back overshadowed Tate. And Tate is an extraordinary woman IMO, and the show has so many high points to it already, but it became almost too much "squee" by then.