View Full Version: Simon Says: the American Idol thread

www >>House-Bound No More >>Simon Says: the American Idol thread


<< Prev | Next >>

Namaste- 02-08-2010

So Jason Castro in all his dread glory was an opener for an act at the little 400-seat music venue where I volunteer last week. I wasn't at that show, but the tales from folks that were are pretty good. They said that he was a nice guy (and he had the new wife with him) but that fans? Mostly teenage girls who were star struck and would ask things like: "Where are the dressing rooms?" "Backstage," they'd tell them. "And how do I get backstage?" "You don't." (People who worked both shows were also very happy to note that the line to get autographs from 83-year-old Ralph Stanley on Saturday was far longer than the line for Jason Castro.) Also ... So Howard Stern is in talks to replace Simon? Oddly enough I think Howard is right. It's the only person I can now think of as Simon's replacement.

Boffle- 02-08-2010

Howard Stern? Excellent. That will kill that show once and for all.

galaxygirl- 03-22-2010

Anybody else insanely excited about the guest mentor for tomorrow's show? Because I am... /sarscam

radiosweetheart- 03-22-2010

Geniuses, each and every one of those talented young people.

galaxygirl- 03-22-2010

I'm really sad I can't mix my meds and the bottle of wine in my fridge, because that might be the only way to get through the next 2 shows.

sautomne- 03-22-2010

Oh c'mon people, if you can't see Miley Cyrus for the obvious child prodigy that she is...

extra_cat- 05-27-2010

Anyone care about the finale this year? I'm glad Lee won. But I would've been glad if Crystal won too. They were both good. I was disappointed that David Cook had a conflict and couldn't appear with all the other idols.

radiosweetheart- 05-27-2010

I half watched this season. Sometimes I'd have it on, but the only people who registered with me were Crystal and Casey. I think Lee is already well on his way to being another Taylor, only slightly less marketable. I'm sorry, I see nothing about the guy that is even slightly interesting. He bored the piss out of me and that's in the time I knew he existed which was Tuesday and Wednesday. I have no idea how he won. I'm not even sure how he exists. He is boring on legs. Crystal's pretty great, tho. I wish her well and I might buy her single since it was written by one of my ultimate favorite singer songwriters in the history of life, Patty Griffin.

Namaste- 05-28-2010

I can't say that I've ever cared who won. Or for that matter that I ever watched a finale. (Melinda Doolittle is my favorite competitor ever.) I caught a few highlights a couple of times, this season, but that's generally all I've ever done. Crystal strikes me as someone who will have a decent, if not big, career and be able to make her living with music. She's not really "pop," but of course I don't think she wants to be pop. Lee? He's going to join the army of similar bland performers and will end up on the state fair circuit within a couple of years. (Not that Crystal isn't one of a thousand "coffee house circuit" performers, but that's a more defined niche with opportunities for songwriters who can secure a decent livelihood through it, and it requires less mass appeal. I say this judged on the people within that niche who pass through the music club where I work, who make a living on this scale. The more pop oriented need bigger backing groups, bigger venues and bigger crowds to become financially secure.)

extra_cat- 05-28-2010

They're both songwriters so as long as their contracts let them record some of their own songs they'll be a step closer to financial security. I think Mike has the potential to have a good career ahead of him too.

extra_cat- 07-29-2010

Ellen leaves. I think it's a good thing. She's good on her own show, but she was terrible as an Idol judge.

radiosweetheart- 07-30-2010

Does Randy just not have anywhere else to go, or what?

galaxygirl- 07-30-2010

Let's face it, who would want Randy. I've always have found him the most useless of the judges, even Paula occasionally managed to give out good advice.

galaxygirl- 08-19-2010

Word on the street is that Steven Tyler will be joining the show as a judge. Are we gonna need a new title for this thread now Simon is gone?

radiosweetheart- 08-19-2010

How 'bout: This is gonna suck: AI Post-Simon? Or: 4 Hrs a Week to Do Other Things: American Idol S10