View Full Version: Simon Says: the American Idol thread

www >>House-Bound No More >>Simon Says: the American Idol thread


<< Prev | Next >>

radiosweetheart- 04-16-2009

Everyone is SO boring. I don't care who wins. It's a mystery why I keep watching.

galaxygirl- 04-16-2009

I hear ya. I barely watch anything, I just do not care about them. The second performance hour I prefer to watch the DwtS's result show and on Wednesday I watch Lost and see some glimpses of the boringness during a commercial break on ABC. I'm so puzzled about why the hell they can't get their shit together timewise. Even limiting the comments to two judges each, they still manage to run over while in the past they didn't have those problems. I find it VERY knolly that Kara LaGuardia Airport is writing the coronation song. Hmm, I wonder if she has a preference about who she wants to sing it...

radiosweetheart- 04-16-2009

Didn't know Kara was writing the This is My Rainbows and Sunlight Kittens Time song. That's just ridiculous. I kind of hate this show, now. Wish I could turn away.

galaxygirl- 04-16-2009

I know, and it doesn't help that after watching that youtube video of that lady on Britain got Talent, well, those kids on AI are nothing compared to her and her voice.

peggy06- 04-16-2009

I've only watched AI in S7 and 8, but I'll take Adam, Allison and Kris over anybody last year. (David Archuleta had as good a vocal instrument, but he couldn't interpret.) And I grudgingly admit that Danny also knows how to use his voice, though I don't like the stuff he sings. My problem with this season is that I don't think you get as many interesting people with the groups, and the 4-judge panel is a disaster. Also the judges' save gimmick.

melly- 04-25-2009

I know, and it doesn't help that after watching that youtube video of that lady on Britain got Talent, well, those kids on AI are nothing compared to her and her voice. I just saw that lady on youtube. The look on Simon's face was priceless! :shock: I just haven't taken to anybody on Idol this season. Maybe next year.

extra_cat- 04-26-2009

I just haven't taken to anybody on Idol this season. Maybe next year. This year reminds me of the year Jordin Sparks won. I just don't care who wins. Only this year, I actively hope Adam doesn't win and I thought the competitors were more diverse the year Sparks won.

galaxygirl- 04-28-2009

Well, I guess it's official: This is the year of the Judges. Competitors? Who cares. Last year at top 5 we got 2 songs from everyone and got done on time. Now, they can't even get them done on time with the kiddo's only singing one song each. Time management is not their strongest suit. Just kick Kara back on the curb and all is good again. I'd rather keep the old stooges if it means that she goes. I don't care who wins. I do think that Adam is massively overrated and I have no idea how they plan to market him after he wins. Actually I take that back, I have no idea how they plan to market any of them. I even take last year's David Hernandez, who went out as #12, over any of this bunch.

Housewhore4- 04-28-2009

I now cannot stand Adam Lambert. I pretty much had absolutely no taste for him before, but now, I'm fast forwarding. I hate that he did Muse's arrangement of "Feelin' Good". He's trying to be original and that's straight off the CD, and everyone thinks he's genius.

LightMyCandle- 04-29-2009

I don't like Adam either. I just don't get what's so great about them that all the judges just trip over themselves trying to compliment him. He gets up there and screams. Um, wow? :? I know he's going to win but he just bugs the crap out of me. I like Allison but I'm sure she's going home next week. The other three are boring. Kris is okay, but not great.

extra_cat- 05-03-2009

Adam Cook died this morning. :(

Housewhore4- 05-03-2009

Adam Cook died this morning. :( Yeah I heard, very sad to hear :cry: :cry: :cry: :cry: David was so close to him. At least he got to see the brunt of his brothers success. 11 year battle, wow. My heart goes out to the Cook family :cry:

galaxygirl- 05-03-2009

Very,very sad :( Interview with David about the loss of his brother. I didn't think it was possible, but I'm even more amazed by what a great man he is. On a happier note, I'll be seeing him live in July and I'm very excited about it.

galaxygirl- 05-04-2009

I don't usually double post like this, but I thought this deserved a separate post. Message from David to his fans

extra_cat- 05-04-2009

Thanks for the links.