Yes RSH, it's a normal reaction, at I think it is because I want to punch her most of the time as well. Not helped by the fact that I don't think she's as good as they want me to believe.
Namaste- 02-27-2008
The LA Times had a story about David Archuletta's "original" interpretation of "Imagine." Seems it's the arrangement that Eva Cassidy recorded back before her death nearly 10 years ago.
galaxygirl- 02-27-2008
Well, that was mighty underwhelming. I think Amanda and Alexandrea are goners.
radiosweetheart- 02-27-2008
The ladies of Idol haven't lit up my life this year. Last year Melinda rocked my socks weekly but this year...eh is about the best I can come up with.
I vote to add Heart to the "Do not sing" list. Right next to Whitney, Celine, and "I am telling you I'm not going"
galaxygirl- 02-27-2008
The ladies of Idol haven't lit up my life this year. Last year Melinda rocked my socks weekly but this year...eh is about the best I can come up with.
I vote to add Heart to the "Do not sing" list. Right next to Whitney, Celine, and "I am telling you I'm not going"
I loved Melinda and once she got booted it stopped being a singing competition. I love when Simon and co. are saying things like that, when reality tells us that it's everything but a singing competition.
I watched Fantasia sing Summertime on the Tube of You, now that was a stand out performance. I haven't seen anything even remotely like that yet.
radiosweetheart- 02-27-2008
That is so right on. Melinda was perfect week after week-never a wrong note, never a bad performance-when she was voted off it became a beauty contest.
Sadly, I feel we will never have another Clay.
sautomne- 02-27-2008
Thank god for that!
radiosweetheart- 02-27-2008
Just for that-I'm gonna kick your ass!
Badmouthin' Clay Aiken---that's a beatin'.
galaxygirl- 02-27-2008
I don't think the producers ever wanted Clay, or Taylor or even Kelly.
I have a hard time telling the Barbie's apart this season.
radiosweetheart- 02-27-2008
You're probably right, Geeg. The producers want pretty and Tween appealing, not talented and/or musically interesting to anyone old enough to drive.
galaxygirl- 02-27-2008
heard on Ryan's radio show, quote is from one of the AI producers:
"It's something we've waited for for seven seasons now. Sony has agreed to release the Lennon and McCartney songbook to us," producer Nigel Lythgoe told Ryan Seacrest on his KIIS-FM radio show.
"Everyone's so good this season they're saying, 'Yeah, go ahead, please sing the songs.' And especially after Archuleta sang the Lennon song last night. How good was that?"
What.ever. :roll:
I got my tin foil hat firmly on my head, I'm seeing conspiracies everywhere RSH, which is why I believe that they have 'chosen ones' and especially those first two of the three weren't.
amysusanne- 02-27-2008
I want to punch Carly. Is that a normal reaction?
Probably, but tonight was the first night I enjoyed every note she sang.
Oooh! My husband and I have a tattoo parlor and I work at an Irish bar and just pretend I never had a recording contract and that no one wanted to buy my record.
Or, you know, "ooh, I'm Kelly Clarkson and I lived in my car except that I really *didn't* live in my car and was only there when my apartment building caught on fire and did I mention that I was recording demos with Gerry Goffin???".
It's all relative and it's not as if she hasn't said on the show that she had a deal. Sure, she's downplayed it, but I would too. I was actually more annoyed that Archuletta's "what you don't know about me" was AI related. I know they did that for conspiracy theorists, but "I won Junior Star Search" would have been far better because everyone's whispering about it and it's not like anyone gives a shit about Junior Star Search, so it won't lose him votes.
As for Carly's future:Taylor Hicks probably sold less of his AI album than he did of everything they recorded before he was on the show. Who's to say Carly won't have the opposite happen. Granted, it's not hard to outsell 300 albums (she's probably lapped that a dozen times over on itunes by now), but record companies fuck up with artists all the time. If she wins (which she probably won't) she could just as easily find herself with Kelly/Carrie material rather than Ruben/Taylor material and make a decent go of it. I'd never go so far as to say that 19 is better at nurturing an artist, but they are very good at marketing you if they like you.
I don't think anyone I actually like is in danger tonight except for, maybe, A'siah...whose name I just blanked on and may have mangled. I like her and I didn't think she *sucked*, but she was rough and who the hell knows. Voters are weird and fickle and, I guess, if I *really* cared I would be dialing my phone right now, but I don't.
Overall, I think, in spite of the fact that her rendition was a little too cute for such a bitter song, Brooke was both my favorite *and* the best. Amanda and Alexandrea were way at the bottom, but my dream is still that Kady will go home as a personal favor to me. If she doesn't, I'd like her to at least finally go batshit on them all because the girl is very close to blowing. And she couldn't make it more obvious that she has nothing but contempt for Ryan if she hired a skywriter to fly all over the city tomorrow.
edited because artist and audience are two completely different things.
extra_cat- 02-27-2008
It's true that it's not just a singing contest. The fact that Taylor Hicks actually won solidifies that statement! LOL
Brooke and Kristy Lee were my favorites tonight.
sautomne- 02-27-2008
The fact that Taylor Hicks actually won solidifies that statement!
I actually watched most of that season with my grandmother, a very even tempered eighty-three year old woman. Every time Taylor Hicks graced the screen she'd roll her eyes,wave her hands at the screen, and complain during his whole performance. His very existence seemed to offend her. And she always said that he looked like he was having a seizure when he sang.
extra_cat- 02-28-2008
I think the Taylors and Sanjayas of the past have scared them into not picking any really quirky people (like Frat Boy or Fingernail Clippings Guy).
Forumer™ is Voted #1 Free Forum Hosting provider
Build your own community today with the largest message board hosting company.